Thanks Prajna!

I uploaded a couple of your videos here:



Ufopolitics

It all depends on how it will perform under load or if is used to dump in storage banks how fast can replenish what is taken. If a feedback is used to increase rate of replenish we are back to how it may perform under load ... this is all about in any type of such systems, at least this is my opinion and I reserve the right to be wrong.

Quote from: Classic on Jun 26, 2024, 04:46 AMIt all depends on how it will perform under load or if is used to dump in storage banks how fast can replenish what is taken. If a feedback is used to increase rate of replenish we are back to how it may perform under load ... this is all about in any type of such systems, at least this is my opinion and I reserve the right to be wrong.

I'm sure you are right. In any case I want to get it built and tested, then we might have some idea. I picked up my first print today - one half of the base. The other half should be ready tonight and then I have two or three more days of printing next week.

Hello Prajna,

Thanks for all explanation plus videos, yes, they do help a lot to understand your setup!!

What I find very interesting is the way you have been able to achieve a Constant Dual Reciprocating Movement, which is Self-Assisting plus Self Compensated.

The Action and Instant Reaction between all four magnets, just by a Smooth, non-frictional spin of a rotor, just on its own is a great achievement!!

I do not know if you are familiar with Lüling Magnet Motor...back on 1966, but here is a video that I uploaded from the original 35mm Film:


Lüling uses FIRST, a Full Neutralization of Forces between magnets (please, realize at that time Neodymium Magnets were not discovered yet), using one end at an Attraction and the other end at Repulsion, both forces -if they are fully balanced- they will spin very smoothly.

Then He uses a Method* to unbalance the forces just on one end (either Attract or Repulse) therefore, releasing the FULL FORCES of the opposite side, which propels the main rotor.

I have worked before on this and it works, it is just that I decided to use the Repulsion side to unbalance...which resulted in requirement of great forces.

So, I used an Air Piston (Pneumatic System) to do this job...and the Magnetic Forces spin the rotor at over 400 RPM's:


Now looking at your Design Method*, I see an easier way, not requiring great forces, to "unbalance" the repulsion end, without the need to use Pneumatics!

Of course, there are many possibilities here...as to also unbalance the Attract side, which I think it was what Lüling used.

If you would like to read more about my development, it is on Topic below:

LÜLING MAGNET MOTOR BY UFOPOLITICS (overunitymachines.com)

Regards

Ufopolitics

Quote from: Ufopolitics on Jun 26, 2024, 08:26 AMHello Prajna,

Thanks for all explanation plus videos, yes, they do help a lot to understand your setup!!

What I find very interesting is the way you have been able to achieve a Constant Dual Reciprocating Movement, which is Self-Assisting plus Self Compensated.

The Action and Instant Reaction between all four magnets, just by a Smooth, non-frictional spin of a rotor, just on its own is a great achievement!!

I do not know if you are familiar with Lüling Magnet Motor...back on 1966, but here is a video that I uploaded from the original 35mm Film:

Thanks @Ufopolitics, that looks interesting, I will certainly take a look, and thanks for uploading the videos.

What is good about my arrangement is that it makes the best of the inverse square law (1/r^²): when the finger moves out of the magnetic gap the magnets repell strongly because they are close and this assists to pull in the magnets that are spaced on the opposite side of the rotor, which as they approach the newly-introduced finger attract more strongly as the repulsive force of the separating magnets drops off. It is rather a neat arrangement. I'm off to watch the videos you posted and to read the pdf @Classic posted.(1/r^2)